1. News
  2. NXP ICODE 3 vs ICODE SLIX and ICODE SLIX 2?

NXP ICODE 3 vs ICODE SLIX and ICODE SLIX 2?

18 November 2024   |   Industry News

NXP have launched the next generation of their ICODE chip series - the ICODE 3. This chip is an NFC forum Type 5 tag and operates with ISO standard of ISO15693. With 300 bytes of memory and data retention of up to 50 years it has significantly longer life span than the NTAG series.

When comparing to previous ICODE chips there are some small improvements:

  • Read distance: operating maximum of 1.5 meters
  • SELF-ADJUST: The chip automatically adapts to changes in antenna frequency
  • Read speed: a faster read speed on the ICODE 3 of 212 kbit/s vs 53 kbit/s on the older chips.
  • NFC Counter / Mirror: The mirror function can automatically add the scan count to the tag data, like a URL. And also has a write counter which allows functionality to control the count

ICODE 3 vs ICODE SLIX 2 / ICODE SLIX

There's actually a number of ICODE variants including:

  • ICODE 3
  • ICODE 3 TagTamper
  • ICODE DNA
  • ICODE SLIX 2
  • ICODE SLIX
  • ICODE SLIX-S
  • ICODE SLIX-L

These tags all have slight specification variations. But we will focus on the new ICODE 3 compared to the ICODE SLIX 2 and ICODE SLIX.

Core Features

  ICODE SLIX ICODE SLIX 2 ICODE 3
User Memory (Bytes) 112 bytes 316 bytes 300 bytes
EAS Protection 4 byte password 4 byte password 4 byte password
Persistant Quiet No Yes Yes
Original Sign - Yes 32/48 bytes customisable
Memory Protection 4 byte password 4 byte password 4 byte password
Data Retention 50 years 50 years 50 years
Write Endurance 100,000 cycles 100,000 cycles 100,000 cycles
Standards ISO15693
NFC Forum Type 5
ISO15693
NFC Forum Type 5
ISO15693
NFC Forum Type 5
Read Speed (Max) 53 kbit/s 53 kbit/s 212 kbit/s
NFC Mirror - - UID / Counter
Counter - Yes Yes
Capacitance 23.5pf / 97pf 23.5pf 23.5pf / 97pf

 

ICODE Features explained

On the face of it, the differences between the ICODE 3 and ICODE SLIX 2 are minimal. In reality, for the majority of our users, the differences aren't going to be relevant. All three variants of the chip have the same lifespan and standards. However, there are a number of smaller improvements that make the ICODE 3 interesting for more specialist applications. 

Security Features

The enhanced security features may appeal to large-scale ticketing or asset management applications, but they are unlikely to be relevant for most of our customers.

For customers looking for an ICODE chip with enhanced security, there's the ICODE DNA which allows Tag Authentication to 128bit AES. This chip does not allow doesn't allow for mirror of cryptographic data in the same way as the NTAG424. Therefore it is more suited for closed loop specialist applications. 

Read Speed

NXP are advertising a faster read speed on the ICODE 3 of 212 kbit/s vs 53 kbit/s on the older chips.

This feature might be useful for large-scale, multi-tag reading, but most of our customers won't notice a difference. For example scanning with a mobile phone might speed up data transfer by less than 0.005 seconds.

NFC Counter / Mirror

While both the ICODE SLIX 2 and ICODE 3 have an NFC read counter, the ICODE 3 takes this a step further. Firstly, it's the first ICODE to have a mirror function where the scan count can be mirrored dynamically into the tag data - such as a URL.

 Secondly, the ICODE 3 provides an additional Write counter (as well as the Read counter) and provides some functionality to control the counts. 

Capacitance

This gets a little more complicated. To read more we have a separate article on how the capacitance of a chip affects the antenna design.

Like the original ICODE SLIX chip, the new ICODE 3 will be available with both 23.5pf and 97pf capacitance variants. This is important as the higher capacitance allows for a smaller antenna design - ie. smaller tags. 

However, in real terms, we've always preferred the ICODE SLIX 2 to the ICODE SLIX.

Seritag testing shows a good 20% increase in scan performance of the ICODE SLIX compared to other tags. For the ICODE 3 the boost in scan performance will be beneficial.

Automatic SELFAdjust Mechanism Explained

One feature that is new to the ICODE 3 is NXP's SELFAdjust - and we consider this to be something special. To see the benefits, let's look at how NFC tags, especially their antennas, are made.

An NFC tag is composed of three main components: the NFC chip, the antenna, and a structure to hold everything together. The antenna is a loop of wire acting as an inductor which enables the reader to create an electromagnetic field and generate current.

For an NFC tag to work effectively, this coil of wire needs to be tuned to a specific frequency which is close to 13.56 Mhz. Tuning this frequency can be difficult. Even on high quality production lines, within a batch of antennas, the frequency can vary. Causing some NFC tags to not perform as well as expected.

Standard NFC Antenna Tuning
Standard NFC Antenna Tuning

NXP's SELFAdjust mechanism is designed to counteract this. The chip adjusts itself to small changes in antenna frequency to ensure all NFC tags in a batch work consistently. This is crucial when tags are used at their maximum scan distance.

Tuned NFC Antenna with NXP's SELFAdjust
NXP's SELFAdjust mechanism for NFC antenna tuning

 

This technology is clearly important for any NFC tag application but becomes critical when tags are used at the edge of their scan distance performance.

Unfortunately, as far as we can tell from the specifications, this SELFAdjust technology is only available on the 23.5pf version of the chip. As the performance of smaller tags is usually more critical because of the short scan distances, we would think that SELFAdjust would be more useful on the 97pf version. We are clarifying this with NXP to see if this is a datasheet error. 

Is the ICODE 3 worth using ?

Although priced at a 5% premium compared to the ICODE SLIX 2, ICODE 3 is a great chip. This is not a huge difference but it's still 5% for features and performance you may not need. However we expect to see this narrow in the future when more chips become available.

An important consideration is that the ICODE SLIX has little protection against clone chip copies. Therefore we always recommend ICODE SLIX 2 against ICODE SLIX.

The new security features of the ICODE 3 make it ideal for applications that use the maximum scan distance. However, we'd still say the ICODE SLIX 2 is an excellent option until the pricing gap disappears. 

 

what is an nfc tag
What is an NFC Tag ?
A quick intro to NFC tags - what they are, how they are used and the different types of tags
options price list
Options price list
Pricing for our encoding, scanning, ID printing and batching services.
encoding services
NFC Tag encoding
Details of our NFC tag encoding services.
id print services
ID printing
How to order ID / QR code printing on your NFC tags.
uid scan service
UID scan
How you can order a UID scan of your NFC tags.

Latest Articles

Using NFC
A Guide to NFC: NFC Asset Tags and Asset management
A guide to NFC Asset tags and Asset Managment
Range of custom printed NFC labels
Seritag News
Custom Printed NFC Stickers
Explore the five benefits of using Sheet Express NFC Stickers for your project.
Industry News
NXP ICODE 3 vs ICODE SLIX and ICODE SLIX 2?
A comparison of NXP's new ICODE 3 vs the ICODE SLIX / ICODE SLIX 2
Industry News
What is a Digital Product Passport ?
Discover the fundamentals of Digital Product Passports: their definition, implementation process, and their compatibility with your products.
Opinion
STMicroelectronics Launches ST25TA-E Authentication NFC Tag
Will STMicroelectronics launch of the ST25TA-E take the crown from NXP's NTAG424 ?
NHS Hangtag connected to ixkio
Seritag News
NHS chooses ixkio to support mental wellbeing of their staff
NFC hangtags powered by ixkio are being used by NHS trust to help wellbeing amongst staff.
NFC & QR Code Management
Contact
©Copyright 2024 Seritag.
Seritag is a trading name of TabDesk Ltd, a UK Registered company 10474154. VAT Registration Number GB256328005.
Seritag
£